[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: study
Target surface form: studying
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that <t>studying</t> a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=study%2:31:02:: | definition=consider in detail and subject to an analysis in order to discover essential features or meaning | synonyms=analyze, analyse, examine, canvass, canvas | examples=analyze a sonnet by Shakespeare; analyze the evidence in a criminal trial
2. sense_key=study%2:31:03:: | definition=be a student; follow a course of study; be enrolled at an institute of learning
3. sense_key=study%2:39:00:: | definition=give careful consideration to | synonyms=consider | examples=consider the possibility of moving
4. sense_key=study%2:31:00:: | definition=be a student of a certain subject | synonyms=learn, read, take | examples=She is reading for the bar exam
5. sense_key=study%2:31:01:: | definition=learn by reading books | synonyms=hit the books | examples=He is studying geology in his room; I have an exam next week; I must hit the books now
6. sense_key=study%2:31:04:: | definition=think intently and at length, as for spiritual purposes | synonyms=meditate, contemplate | examples=He is meditating in his study

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
 The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "studying" in the given context. The target lemma is "study" and the surface form is "studying".

Let me analyze the context:
- The sentence is: "It turns out that <t>studying</t> a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"
- The context is about scientific research on retinoblastoma (a tumor) leading to insights about cancer.
- Samuel Broder is talking about how researching/analyzing this specific tumor led to fundamental insights.
- This is clearly in the context of scientific research and analysis.

Now let's look at the candidate senses:

1. sense_key=study%2:31:02:: | definition=consider in detail and subject to an analysis in order to discover essential features or meaning | synonyms=analyze, analyse, examine, canvass, canvas | examples=analyze a sonnet by Shakespeare; analyze the evidence in a criminal trial
   - This seems to fit well. The context is about analyzing/examining the tumor to discover essential features (how cancer works).

2. sense_key=study%2:31:03:: | definition=be a student; follow a course of study; be enrolled at an institute of learning
   - This is about being a student at a school. Doesn't fit - they're not talking about enrolling in classes.

3. sense_key=study%2:39:00:: | definition=give careful consideration to | synonyms=consider | examples=consider the possibility of moving
   - This is more general consideration. While related, the context suggests deeper analysis/research rather than just consideration.

4. sense_key=study%2:31:00:: | definition=be a student of a certain subject | synonyms=learn, read, take | examples=She is reading for the bar exam
   - This is about being a student of a subject. The context isn't about someone being a student, but about the scientific investigation of a tumor.

5. sense_key=study%2:31:01:: | definition=learn by reading books | synonyms=hit the books | examples=He is studying geology in his room; I have an exam next week; I must hit the books now
   - This is about academic studying for exams or courses. The context is about scientific research, not hitting the books for a class.

6. sense_key=study%2:31:04:: | definition=think intently and at length, as for spiritual purposes | synonyms=meditate, contemplate | examples=He is meditating in his study
   - This is about meditation/contemplation. Doesn't fit the scientific context.

The best fit is sense 1: "consider in detail and subject to an analysis in order to discover essential features or meaning".

In the context, "studying a tragic but uncommon tumor" means analyzing/examining the tumor scientifically to discover essential features (fundamental insights about cancer). The synonyms "analyze, examine" fit perfectly here. This is about scientific research and analysis, not about being a student or learning from books.

The context mentions "basic research" later in the quote, which confirms this is the research/analysis sense.

So the answer should be sense_index: 1.


attempt_kind: initial

status: success

[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: tragic
Target surface form: tragic
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a <t>tragic</t> but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=tragic%5:00:00:sad:00 | definition=very sad; especially involving grief or death or destruction | synonyms=tragical | examples=a tragic face; a tragic plight
2. sense_key=tragic%3:01:00:: | definition=of or relating to or characteristic of tragedy | examples=tragic hero

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

finish_reason: stop

role: assistant

reasoning_content:
The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "tragic" in the given context.

Let me analyze the context:
- The passage is about retinoblastoma, a rare eye cancer in children.
- Samuel Broder says: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"
- The tumor is described as "tragic but uncommon"
- The context involves a tumor that affects children (retinoblastoma), which is sad and involves potential death/destruction.

Now let's look at the candidate senses:

1. sense_key=tragic%5:00:00:sad:00 | definition=very sad; especially involving grief or death or destruction | synonyms=tragical | examples=a tragic face; a tragic plight
2. sense_key=tragic%3:01:00:: | definition=of or relating to or characteristic of tragedy | examples=tragic hero

Sense 1 means "very sad; especially involving grief or death or destruction" - this fits because retinoblastoma is a tumor that affects children, causes suffering, and can lead to death. The context emphasizes the human suffering aspect ("tragic but uncommon tumor").

Sense 2 means "of or relating to or characteristic of tragedy" (like literary tragedy) - this would apply to things like "tragic hero" or "tromic flaw" in drama. The context is about a real medical condition, not a literary genre.

The phrase "tragic but uncommon tumor" clearly uses "tragic" to mean something causing sadness/grief/destruction (sense 1), not in the literary/dramatic sense (sense 2). A tumor that blinds and kills children is "very sad; especially involving grief or death or destruction."

Therefore, sense 1 is the correct choice.

The user wants only a JSON object like {"sense_index": 3}. Since the candidates are numbered 1 and 2, I should return {"sense_index": 1}.

format: unknown

native_finish_reason: stop

provider: SiliconFlow

currency: USD


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: uncommon
Target surface form: uncommon
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but <t>uncommon</t> tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=uncommon%3:00:00:: | definition=not common or ordinarily encountered; unusually great in amount or remarkable in character or kind | examples=uncommon birds; frost and floods are uncommon during these months
2. sense_key=uncommon%5:00:00:extraordinary:00 | definition=marked by an uncommon quality; especially superlative or extreme of its kind; -J.R.Lowell | synonyms=rare | examples=what is so rare as a day in June; a rare skill

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "uncommon" in the given context.

 Let me analyze the context:
 - The text is about retinoblastoma, a rare eye cancer
 - The quote says: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"
 - So "uncommon" here is describing the tumor (retinoblastoma)
 - The meaning is that this tumor is not common/rare

 Now let's look at the candidate senses:

 1. sense_key=uncommon%3:00:00:: | definition=not common or ordinarily encountered; unusually great in amount or remarkable in character or kind | examples=uncommon birds; frost and floods are uncommon during these months

 2. sense_key=uncommon%5:00:00:extraordinary:00 | definition=marked by an uncommon quality; especially superlative or extreme of its kind; -J.R.Lowell | synonyms=rare | examples=what is so rare as a day in June; a rare skill

 Wait, looking at the definitions:
 - Sense 1: "not common or ordinarily encountered" - this fits the context of a rare tumor
 - Sense 2: "marked by an uncommon quality; especially superlative or extreme of its kind" - this seems to mean something like "exceptional" or "remarkable" in a positive sense, like "rare skill"

 In the context, "uncommon tumor" means the tumor is rare, not frequently encountered. This aligns with sense 1.

 However, I need to look carefully at the sense keys. The first one is uncommon%3:00:00:: which is the standard adjective sense meaning "not common". The second one is uncommon%5:00:00:extraordinary:00 which seems to be a satellite adjective (indicated by the 5) linked to "extraordinary".

 Actually, looking at WordNet structure:
 - uncommon%3:00:00:: is the main sense: "not common or ordinarily encountered; unusually great in amount or remarkable in character or kind"
 - uncommon%5:00:00:extraordinary:00 is a satellite sense: "marked by an uncommon quality; especially superlative or extreme of its kind"

 But wait, in the context "tragic but uncommon tumor", the meaning is clearly "rare" or "not frequently occurring". This would be sense 1.

 However, looking at the examples for sense 2: "what is so rare as a day in June; a rare skill" - this suggests sense 2 is also about rarity.

 Let me reconsider. In WordNet:
 - Sense 1 (uncommon%3:00:00::) is the direct antonym of "common". It means not common, rare.
 - Sense 2 (uncommon%5:00:00:extraordinary:00) is a satellite of "extraordinary" and means something like "exceptional" or "remarkable".

 Actually, looking at the definition for sense 2 again: "marked by an uncommon quality; especially superlative or extreme of its kind" - this suggests something is uncommon because it's exceptional, outstanding, or extreme.

 In the context of the tumor, it's "uncommon" because it's rare, not because it's exceptional or superlative. Retinoblastoma is a rare disease (uncommon), not necessarily an exceptional or extraordinary one in the sense of being remarkable.

 The phrase "tragic but uncommon tumor" suggests that while it's tragic, it's not common (i.e., it doesn't happen often). This is clearly sense 1.

 But I need to check the indexing. The user asks for the "sense_index". Looking at the candidate senses:
 1. sense_key=uncommon%3:00:00:: ...
 2. sense_key=uncommon%5:00:00:extraordinary:00 ...

 So the indices are 1 and 2.

 Sense 1 is the correct choice here because:
 - It refers to something not ordinarily encountered (rare)
 - The tumor is described as uncommon meaning rare/infrequent
 - Sense 2 refers to something being extraordinary or exceptional in quality, which doesn't fit a tumor (even though the tumor is tragic, the "uncommon" here refers to its frequency, not its exceptional nature)

 Wait, actually looking at the synonyms for sense 2: "rare". And the examples include "what is so rare as a day in June". This could also mean infrequent.

 But the key difference is:
 - Sense 1: "not common or ordinarily encountered" - this is about frequency/occurrence
 - Sense 2: "marked by an uncommon quality; especially superlative or extreme of its kind" - this is about quality/character

 In the context: "studying a tragic but uncommon tumor" - the tumor is uncommon because it's rare (not many cases), not because it has some uncommon/superlative quality.

 Therefore, sense 1 is correct.

 The answer should be: {"sense_index": 1}

provider: DeepInfra


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: make
Target surface form: made
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor <t>made</t> possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=make%2:41:00:: | definition=engage in | synonyms=do | examples=make love, not war; make an effort
2. sense_key=make%2:30:00:: | definition=give certain properties to something | synonyms=get | examples=get someone mad; She made us look silly
3. sense_key=make%2:36:00:: | definition=make or cause to be or to become | synonyms=create | examples=make a mess in one's office; create a furor
4. sense_key=make%2:32:00:: | definition=cause to do; cause to act in a specified manner | synonyms=induce, stimulate, cause, have, get | examples=The ads induced me to buy a VCR; My children finally got me to buy a computer
5. sense_key=make%2:36:08:: | definition=give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally | synonyms=cause, do | examples=cause a commotion; make a stir
6. sense_key=make%2:36:01:: | definition=create or manufacture a man-made product | synonyms=produce, create | examples=We produce more cars than we can sell; The company has been making toys for two centuries
7. sense_key=make%2:31:00:: | definition=make, formulate, or derive in the mind | synonyms=draw | examples=I draw a line here; draw a conclusion
8. sense_key=make%2:36:15:: | definition=compel or make somebody or something to act in a certain way | examples=People cannot be made to integrate just by passing a law!; Heat makes you sweat
9. sense_key=make%2:36:09:: | definition=create by artistic means | synonyms=create | examples=create a poem; Schoenberg created twelve-tone music
10. sense_key=make%2:40:01:: | definition=earn on some commercial or business transaction; earn as salary or wages | synonyms=gain, take in, clear, earn, realize, realise | examples=How much do you make a month in your new job?; She earns a lot in her new job
11. sense_key=make%2:36:05:: | definition=create or design, often in a certain way | synonyms=do | examples=Do my room in blue; I did this piece in wood to express my love for the forest
12. sense_key=make%2:42:05:: | definition=to compose or represent: | synonyms=form, constitute | examples=This wall forms the background of the stage setting; The branches made a roof
13. sense_key=make%2:38:02:: | definition=reach a goal, e.g., | synonyms=reach, get to, progress to | examples=make the first team; We made it!
14. sense_key=make%2:42:00:: | definition=be or be capable of being changed or made into | examples=He makes a great host; He will make a fine father
15. sense_key=make%2:36:11:: | definition=make by shaping or bringing together constituents | examples=make a dress; make a cake
16. sense_key=make%2:36:12:: | definition=perform or carry out | examples=make a decision; make a move
17. sense_key=make%2:36:13:: | definition=make by combining materials and parts | synonyms=construct, build | examples=this little pig made his house out of straw; Some eccentric constructed an electric brassiere warmer
18. sense_key=make%2:30:15:: | definition=change from one form into another | examples=make water into wine; make lead into gold
19. sense_key=make%2:29:08:: | definition=act in a certain way so as to acquire | examples=make friends; make enemies
20. sense_key=make%2:41:03:: | definition=charge with a function; charge to be | synonyms=name, nominate | examples=She was named Head of the Committee; She was made president of the club
21. sense_key=make%2:40:02:: | definition=achieve a point or goal | synonyms=have, get | examples=Nicklaus had a 70; The Brazilian team got 4 goals
22. sense_key=make%2:38:00:: | definition=reach a destination, either real or abstract | synonyms=reach, attain, hit, arrive at, gain | examples=We hit Detroit by noon; The water reached the doorstep
23. sense_key=make%2:31:13:: | definition=institute, enact, or establish | synonyms=lay down, establish | examples=make laws
24. sense_key=make%2:41:13:: | definition=carry out or commit | examples=make a mistake; commit a faux-pas
25. sense_key=make%2:41:01:: | definition=form by assembling individuals or constituents | examples=Make a quorum
26. sense_key=make%2:36:04:: | definition=organize or be responsible for | synonyms=hold, throw, have, give | examples=hold a reception; have, throw, or make a party
27. sense_key=make%2:30:02:: | definition=put in order or neaten | synonyms=make up | examples=make the bed; make up a room
28. sense_key=make%2:38:05:: | definition=head into a specified direction | synonyms=take | examples=The escaped convict took to the hills; We made for the mountains
29. sense_key=make%2:29:00:: | definition=have a bowel movement | synonyms=stool, defecate, shit, take a shit, take a crap, ca-ca | examples=The dog had made in the flower beds
30. sense_key=make%2:42:09:: | definition=undergo fabrication or creation | examples=This wool makes into a nice sweater
31. sense_key=make%2:42:13:: | definition=be suitable for | examples=Wood makes good furniture
32. sense_key=make%2:42:12:: | definition=add up to | examples=four and four make eight
33. sense_key=make%2:42:11:: | definition=amount to | examples=This salary increase makes no difference to my standard of living
34. sense_key=make%2:42:15:: | definition=constitute the essence of | examples=Clothes make the man
35. sense_key=make%2:39:12:: | definition=appear to begin an activity | examples=He made to speak but said nothing in the end; She made as if to say hello to us
36. sense_key=make%2:38:10:: | definition=proceed along a path | synonyms=work | examples=work one's way through the crowd; make one's way into the forest
37. sense_key=make%2:38:15:: | definition=reach in time | examples=We barely made the plane
38. sense_key=make%2:36:10:: | definition=gather and light the materials for | examples=make a fire
39. sense_key=make%2:36:07:: | definition=prepare for eating by applying heat | synonyms=cook, fix, ready, prepare | examples=Cook me dinner, please; can you make me an omelette?
40. sense_key=make%2:35:13:: | definition=induce to have sex | synonyms=seduce, score | examples=Harry finally seduced Sally; Did you score last night?
41. sense_key=make%2:32:14:: | definition=assure the success of | examples=A good review by this critic will make your play!
42. sense_key=make%2:32:09:: | definition=represent fictitiously, as in a play, or pretend to be or act like | synonyms=pretend, make believe | examples=She makes like an actress
43. sense_key=make%2:31:10:: | definition=consider as being | examples=It wasn't the problem some people made it
44. sense_key=make%2:31:12:: | definition=calculate as being | examples=I make the height about 100 feet
45. sense_key=make%2:30:10:: | definition=cause to be enjoyable or pleasurable | examples=make my day
46. sense_key=make%2:30:14:: | definition=favor the development of | examples=Practice makes the winner
47. sense_key=make%2:30:12:: | definition=develop into | examples=He will make a splendid father!
48. sense_key=make%2:29:06:: | definition=behave in a certain way | examples=make merry
49. sense_key=make%2:29:01:: | definition=eliminate urine | synonyms=urinate, piddle, puddle, micturate, piss, pee | examples=Again, the cat had made on the expensive rug

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) on the word "made" (lemma "make") in the given context.

 Let me analyze the context:
 The sentence is: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor <t>made</t> possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"

 The structure is: "studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights"

 This is a causative construction where "make" means to cause something to happen or to enable something. The studying of the tumor caused/enabled the insights to be possible.

 Let me look at the candidate senses:

 1. engage in - doesn't fit
 2. give certain properties to something - not quite
 3. make or cause to be or to become - possible, but let's check others
 4. cause to do; cause to act in a specified manner - this is about causing someone to do something, not quite right
 5. give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally - this looks promising. "give rise to" fits well with "made possible"
 6. create or manufacture a man-made product - no
 7. make, formulate, or derive in the mind - no
 8. compel or make somebody or something to act in a certain way - no
 9. create by artistic means - no
 10. earn - no
 11. create or design - no
 12. to compose or represent - no
 13. reach a goal - no
 14. be or be capable of being changed - no
 15. make by shaping - no
 16. perform or carry out - no
 17. make by combining materials - no
 18. change from one form - no
 19. act in a certain way so as to acquire - no
 20. charge with a function - no
 21. achieve a point - no
 22. reach a destination - no
 23. institute, enact - no
 24. carry out or commit - no
 25. form by assembling - no
 26. organize or be responsible for - no
 27. put in order - no
 28. head into - no
 29. have a bowel movement - no
 30. undergo fabrication - no
 31. be suitable for - no
 32. add up to - no
 33. amount to - no
 34. constitute the essence of - no
 35. appear to begin - no
 36. proceed along - no
 37. reach in time - no
 38. gather and light - no
 39. prepare for eating - no
 40. induce to have sex - no
 41. assure the success of - no
 42. represent fictitiously - no
 43. consider as being - no
 44. calculate as being - no
 45. cause to be enjoyable - no
 46. favor the development of - no
 47. develop into - no
 48. behave in a certain way - no
 49. eliminate urine - no

 Now between sense 3 and sense 5:

 Sense 3: make or cause to be or to become | synonyms=create | examples=make a mess in one's office; create a furor
 Sense 5: give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally | synonyms=cause, do | examples=cause a commotion; make a stir

 The phrase "made possible" is a specific construction. In this context, studying the tumor gave rise to/caused the insights to be possible.

 Actually, looking at sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally" - this fits well with "made possible". The studying of the tumor gave rise to/caused the possibility of insights.

 But wait, sense 3 is "make or cause to be or to become". The structure here is "made [object] [adjective/predicate]" - "made possible some fundamental insights" (or "made some fundamental insights possible").

 Actually, looking at the word order: "made possible some fundamental insights" - this is "make + adjective + object" or "make + object + adjective" (with inversion).

 The sense "give rise to" (sense 5) seems most appropriate because:
 - It means to cause something to happen or occur
 - The tumor study caused the insights to become possible
 - Synonyms include "cause"

 But let me check sense 3 again: "make or cause to be or to become". This could also fit: "cause [the insights] to be possible".

 However, sense 5 specifically mentions "give rise to" which is very close to the meaning here. The examples for sense 5 are "cause a commotion; make a stir" - these are about causing events/situations.

 The examples for sense 3 are "make a mess", "create a furor" - these are about creating things/situations.

 In the phrase "made possible", we're dealing with a causative construction where "make" means to cause or render.

 Actually, looking at WordNet sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally" - this is the sense for "make" when used as in "make a stir", "cause a commotion".

 But "make possible" is slightly different. It's causing something to be possible.

 Let me look at sense 2: "give certain properties to something" - examples: "get someone mad", "She made us look silly". This is the "make + object + adjective" construction.

 But in the sentence, we have "made possible some fundamental insights" which is equivalent to "made some fundamental insights possible". So this is the "make + object + adjective" construction, which is sense 2: "give certain properties to something".

 Wait, sense 2: "give certain properties to something" | synonyms=get | examples=get someone mad; She made us look silly

 Yes! "She made us look silly" = cause us to be silly. "made possible some fundamental insights" = cause the insights to be possible.

 So sense 2 seems to fit the syntactic pattern best.

 But sense 5 is also about causing: "give rise to; cause to happen or occur".

 Let me think about the difference:
 - Sense 2: "give certain properties to something" - this is about causing a state or condition (make someone mad, make someone look silly, make something possible)
 - Sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen" - this is about causing an event (make a stir, cause a commotion)

 In the sentence: "studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights"

 This is causing the insights to be possible (a state), or causing the possibility of insights.

 Actually, "insights" are not exactly events, but the "possibility" is a state.

 But looking at the example for sense 5: "make a stir" - a stir is an event/commotion.
 Looking at sense 2: "She made us look silly" - looking silly is a state/property.

 "Made possible" fits better with sense 2 (giving the property of being possible) or sense 5 (giving rise to/causing).

 However, in WordNet, the sense "make possible" is often sense 5 or sense 2 depending on the exact semantics.

 Let me reconsider the sentence structure. The phrase is "made possible some fundamental insights". This is a bit archaic/word order inverted. Normally: "made some fundamental insights possible".

 This is definitely the "cause to be" meaning.

 Looking at the candidates again:

 Sense 3: "make or cause to be or to become" - examples: "make a mess", "create a furor"
 Sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen or occur" - examples: "cause a commotion", "make a stir"

 Actually, looking at the Princeton WordNet definitions:

 make.v.05: give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally; "cause a commotion"; "make a stir"

 make.v.02: give certain properties to something; "get someone mad"; "She made us look silly"

 make.v.03: make or cause to be or to become; "make a mess in one's office"; "create a furor"

 Wait, sense 3 and sense 5 are similar. Let me check the actual WordNet keys:

 The user provided:
 2. sense_key=make%2:30:00:: | definition=give certain properties to something | synonyms=get | examples=get someone mad; She made us look silly
 3. sense_key=make%2:36:00:: | definition=make or cause to be or to become | synonyms=create | examples=make a mess in one's office; create a furor
 5. sense_key=make%2:36:08:: | definition=give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally | synonyms=cause, do | examples=cause a commotion; make a stir

 So sense 2 is about giving properties (make someone mad).
 Sense 3 is about causing to be/become (make a mess, create).
 Sense 5 is about giving rise to/causing to happen (make a stir).

 In "made possible some fundamental insights", we are causing the insights to be possible. This is causing a state.

 But "make possible" is often considered a phrasal verb meaning "to enable" or "allow".

 Actually, looking at the specific construction "make possible", in WordNet this might map to sense 5 (cause to happen) or sense 3 (cause to be).

 But let's look at the context again. The full quote is:
 "studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights"

 This means that the study enabled/caused the insights to be possible. It gave rise to the insights.

 Sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen or occur" - this fits well with "made possible". The study gave rise to the possibility of insights.

 However, sense 2 "give certain properties to something" could also fit: the study gave the property of "possible" to the insights.

 But "possible" is an adjective, and sense 2 specifically mentions giving properties, with examples like "make someone mad" (mad = adjective).

 Sense 3 "make or cause to be or to become" with examples like "make a mess" (mess = noun).

 So syntactically, "make + adjective" (make possible) fits sense 2 better.

 But wait, in the sentence, "possible" is followed by "some fundamental insights", so "possible" is functioning as a predicate adjective or perhaps as part of a complex predicate.

 Actually, looking at the structure: "made possible some fundamental insights" - here "possible" is an object complement. The structure is [subject] made [object] [complement].

 This is the "make + object + adjective" construction, which is sense 2.

 But let me check if there's a specific sense for "make possible". In many WSD datasets, "make possible" is often tagged with the sense "cause to be" or "render".

 Looking at the options, sense 2 (give certain properties to something) seems the most accurate for the syntactic construction "make [something] [adjective]".

 However, sense 5 (give rise to) captures the semantic meaning of enabling/causing.

 But sense 2's examples include "She made us look silly" which is exactly the same structure: make + object + predicate (adjective/phrase).

 "Made possible some fundamental insights" = made some fundamental insights possible.

 So I think sense 2 is the correct choice.

 Wait, but I need to be careful. Let me look at the WordNet sense keys again.

 Sense 2: make%2:30:00:: - this is the "change" frame (30)
 Sense 3: make%2:36:00:: - this is the "creation" frame (36)
 Sense 5: make%2:36:08:: - also creation frame

 Actually, looking at WordNet:
 - make%2:30:00:: is "change" - give certain properties to something
 - make%2:36:00:: is "creation" - make or cause to be or to become

 But "make possible" is not really about creation, it's about causation/change of state.

 Let me reconsider sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen or occur". The example "make a stir" - a stir is a noun, but it represents an event.

 In "made possible some fundamental insights", if we view "possible" as part of the verb phrase "make possible" meaning "enable", then it's about causing something to be possible.

 But looking at the actual WordNet entry for sense 2 (make%2:30:00::):
 Definition: give certain properties to something
 Examples: "get someone mad"; "She made us look silly"; "He made a fool of himself at the meeting"; "Don't make this into a big deal"; "This invention will make you a millionaire"; "Make yourself clear"

 This is the "make + object + adjective/noun phrase" construction.

 In our sentence: "made possible some fundamental insights" - this is "make + object + adjective" where the object is "some fundamental insights" and the adjective is "possible", but with inverted word order (poetic/formal).

 So sense 2 fits perfectly.

 But wait, is there a sense specifically for "make possible"? Let me check if any of the senses mention "possible" or "enable".

 Sense 5: "give rise to; cause to happen" - synonyms: cause, do
 Sense 8: "compel or make somebody or something to act in a certain way" - this is different

 Actually, looking at the sentence again, "made possible" could be interpreted as "rendered possible" or "enabled".

 In WordNet, "make possible" is typically sense 5 or sense 2 depending on the exact framing.

 But given the examples:
 - Sense 2: "She made us look silly" (make + object + adjective)
 - Sense 5: "make a stir" (make + noun/event)

 Our case is make + object + adjective (possible), so sense 2.

 However, I want to double-check sense 3: "make or cause to be or to become". This could also fit "make [insights] [possible]".

 But sense 3 examples are "make a mess", "create a furor" - these are creating things, not causing states.

 Sense 2 is specifically about giving properties (like "possible").

 Therefore, I choose sense 2.

 Wait, I need to look at the index numbers. The user lists them as:
 1. sense_key=...
 2. sense_key=...
 etc.

 So sense 2 is index 2.

 But let me reconsider one more time. Is there any other sense that could fit?

 Sense 42: assure the success of - "A good review by this critic will make your play!" - this is different.

 Sense 45: cause to be enjoyable - "make my day" - different.

 Actually, looking at the phrase "made possible", this is often used in the sense of "enabled" or "allowed to happen".

 In the context: "studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights"

 This means the study enabled the insights.

 In WordNet, the sense for "make possible" is often sense 5 (cause to happen) or sense 2 (cause to be).

 But looking at the actual WordNet 3.0 or 3.1 entries:

 make.v.2: give certain properties to something; "get someone mad"; "She made us look silly"; "He made a fool of himself at the meeting"; "Don't make this into a big deal"; "This invention will make you a millionaire"; "Make yourself clear"

 make.v.5: give rise to; cause to happen or occur, not always intentionally; "cause a commotion"; "make a stir"; "cause an accident"

 make.v.3: make or cause to be or to become; "make a mess in one's office"; "create a furor"

 The phrase "make possible" is not explicitly listed in the examples, but "make yourself clear" in sense 2 is similar (make + object + adjective).

 Also, "make possible" would be causing something to have the property of being possible.

 So I think sense 2 (index 2) is correct.

 But I want to check if there's any chance it's sense 5. "Give rise to" - did the study give rise to the insights? Yes. But the specific construction "make possible" is more about the property/ability.

 Actually, looking at the sentence structure once more: "made possible some fundamental insights"

 If we rearrange: "made some fundamental insights possible"

 This is definitely the resultative construction (make + object + adjective complement), which maps to sense 2.

 Therefore, the answer should be {"sense_index": 2}.

 Wait, I should verify the index. The list starts at 1, so:
 1. sense_key=make%2:41:00::
 2. sense_key=make%2:30:00::
 ...

 So yes, sense 2 is index 2.

 But I want to check one more thing. Could it be sense 3?

 Sense 3: "make or cause to be or to become"
 Example: "make a mess"

 "Make a mess" is creating a mess.
 "Make possible" is not creating possibility, but rather causing something to be possible.

 Actually, "make" in "make possible" is a causative verb meaning "cause to be".

 In WordNet, sense 2 is "give certain properties to something" which is exactly "cause to be [adjective]".

 Sense 3 is "make or cause to be or to become" which is more general.

 But sense 2 is more specific to the adjective complement construction.

 I think sense 2 is the best choice.

 Final check: The target surface form is "made", which is past tense of "make". The context is "made possible some fundamental insights".

 Yes, sense 2.

provider: ModelRun


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: possible
Target surface form: possible
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made <t>possible</t> some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=possible%3:00:00:: | definition=capable of happening or existing | examples=a breakthrough may be possible next year; anything is possible
2. sense_key=possible%3:00:04:: | definition=existing in possibility | synonyms=potential | examples=a potential problem; possible uses of nuclear power

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "possible" in the given context.

 Let me analyze the context:
 The sentence is: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made <t>possible</t> some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"

 The structure here is "made possible [something]" - this is a causative construction where studying the tumor enabled/caused the insights to become possible or actual.

 Now let's look at the candidate senses:

 1. sense_key=possible%3:00:00:: | definition=capable of happening or existing | examples=a breakthrough may be possible next year; anything is possible
    - This seems to be the general sense of "possible" meaning something can happen or exist.

 2. sense_key=possible%3:00:04:: | definition=existing in possibility | synonyms=potential | examples=a potential problem; possible uses of nuclear power
    - This seems to emphasize something that is potential, not yet actual, existing only as a possibility.

 In the context: "made possible some fundamental insights"
 - Here, "possible" is being used to describe that the insights became achievable or capable of being realized/understood thanks to the study.
 - The construction "make possible" typically means "to enable" or "to render capable of happening."
 - The insights are things that can now happen/exist (be discovered/understood) because of the research.

 Sense 1 (capable of happening or existing) fits better here because:
 - The insights are now capable of being understood/achieved
 - It's about the capability or feasibility of the insights coming into being

 Sense 2 (existing in possibility/potential) doesn't fit as well because:
 - The sentence is saying the study made the insights possible (enabled them), not that the insights merely exist as potentialities
 - While "potential" is related, the specific usage here is about enabling something to happen, which aligns with "capable of happening"

 Actually, let me reconsider. In "made possible some fundamental insights", we're talking about rendering something possible that wasn't before. The insights become achievable or feasible.

 Looking at the examples:
 - Sense 1: "a breakthrough may be possible next year" - this is about capability/feasibility
 - Sense 2: "possible uses of nuclear power" - this is about potential uses, things that could exist but don't necessarily yet

 In our sentence, the insights are being made capable of being discovered/understood. They are rendered achievable.

 However, I should look carefully at whether this is sense 1 or sense 2.

 Sense 2 is often used attributively: "a possible solution", "possible side effects", "possible uses" - meaning potential, not necessarily actual.

 Sense 1 is often used predicatively: "it is possible", "make it possible" - meaning capable of happening.

 In "made possible some fundamental insights", we have "made possible" + object. This is using "possible" as a complement to "made" (predicative use), describing the state of the insights after the making.

 The insights are made capable of happening/existing (being discovered/understood).

 Therefore, sense 1 seems correct.

 Wait, let me double-check the WordNet sense distinctions. In WordNet:
 - possible%3:00:00:: is the first sense, usually the most general one.
 - possible%3:00:04:: is the "potential" sense.

 In the sentence "studying... made possible some fundamental insights", the meaning is that studying enabled these insights to occur/be discovered. This is about capability/feasibility (sense 1), not about potentiality in the abstract (sense 2).

 Sense 2 examples: "a potential problem; possible uses of nuclear power" - these are about things that are potential, not actual.
 Sense 1 examples: "a breakthrough may be possible next year; anything is possible" - these are about capability.

 The insights were not previously capable of being understood, now they are. So sense 1.

 Actually, looking at the specific construction "make possible", this is an idiom meaning "to enable" or "to allow to happen". This aligns with sense 1 (capable of happening).

 So my answer should be sense_index: 1.


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: insight
Target surface form: insights
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental <t>insights</t> about the most basic workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=insight%1:09:02:: | definition=clear or deep perception of a situation | synonyms=penetration
2. sense_key=insight%1:12:00:: | definition=a feeling of understanding | synonyms=perceptiveness, perceptivity
3. sense_key=insight%1:09:01:: | definition=the clear (and often sudden) understanding of a complex situation | synonyms=brainstorm, brainwave
4. sense_key=insight%1:09:00:: | definition=grasping the inner nature of things intuitively | synonyms=sixth sense

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
 The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "insights" in the given context. I need to choose between 4 candidate senses.

Let me analyze the context:
- The text is about scientific research on cancer, specifically the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene.
- Dr. Thaddeus Dryja discovered a gene that controls retinal cell growth.
- This discovery opened a field of cancer study.
- The quote from Samuel Broder says: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental <t>insights</t> about the most basic workings of cancer"

Key aspects:
- "fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"
- This refers to deep understanding of how cancer works at a basic level
- It's about understanding the mechanisms/nature of cancer
- It's scientific knowledge/perception

Now let's look at the candidate senses:

1. sense_key=insight%1:09:02:: | definition=clear or deep perception of a situation | synonyms=penetration
   - This seems to fit "deep perception" of cancer workings
   - "Penetration" suggests getting to the heart of the matter

2. sense_key=insight%1:12:00:: | definition=a feeling of understanding | synonyms=perceptiveness, perceptivity
   - This is more about the feeling/state of understanding rather than the understanding itself
   - The context is about actual scientific understanding/discoveries, not just a feeling

3. sense_key=insight%1:09:01:: | definition=the clear (and often sudden) understanding of a complex situation | synonyms=brainstorm, brainwave
   - "Brainstorm" and "brainwave" suggest sudden flashes of insight
   - While scientific discoveries can be sudden, the context emphasizes "fundamental insights" about basic workings, suggesting deep understanding rather than sudden flashes
   - Also, "brainstorm" might not fit the plural "insights" as well in this scientific context

4. sense_key=insight%1:09:00:: | definition=grasping the inner nature of things intuitively | synonyms=sixth sense
   - "Intuitively" and "sixth sense" suggest intuition rather than scientific analysis
   - The context is about scientific research, not intuition

Between sense 1 and sense 3:
- Sense 1: "clear or deep perception of a situation" - emphasizes depth and clarity of perception
- Sense 3: "clear (and often sudden) understanding" - emphasizes suddenness

The context mentions "fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer" - this suggests deep, penetrating understanding of the mechanisms. The word "fundamental" suggests getting to the core/nature of things.

Sense 1 with "penetration" as a synonym seems to fit well with understanding the "basic workings" - penetrating to the core of how cancer works.

However, let me reconsider. In WordNet, these senses are often distinguished by whether they refer to:
- The cognitive state of understanding (sense 2)
- The sudden realization (sense 3)
- The deep perception/penetration (sense 1)
- The intuitive grasp (sense 4)

In scientific contexts, "insights" often refers to deep understandings or penetrating perceptions that reveal how something works. The phrase "fundamental insights about the most basic workings" suggests deep perception/penetration into the nature of cancer.

But I should check the WordNet hierarchy:
- insight%1:09:02:: (clear or deep perception of a situation) - noun.cognition
- insight%1:09:01:: (the clear and often sudden understanding) - noun.cognition
- insight%1:09:00:: (grasping the inner nature intuitively) - noun.cognition
- insight%1:12:00:: (a feeling of understanding) - noun.feeling

Sense 1 and 3 are both about cognition/perception. The difference is:
- Sense 1: deep perception (penetration)
- Sense 3: sudden understanding (brainstorm)

In the context of cancer research progress described here, where studying one tumor led to understanding fundamental mechanisms of cancer broadly, this is about deep perception/penetration into the disease mechanisms, not necessarily sudden flashes of insight (though discoveries can be sudden, the text emphasizes the fundamental nature of the understanding).

Also, looking at the synonyms:
- Sense 1: penetration - fits with understanding "basic workings" deeply
- Sense 3: brainstorm, brainwave - these are more about the moment of discovery

The text says "made possible some fundamental insights" - this refers to the resulting knowledge/understanding, not necessarily the moment of sudden realization. It's about the deep understanding gained.

Therefore, sense 1 seems best: "clear or deep perception of a situation" with synonym "penetration".

Wait, I should double-check the WordNet sense keys to make sure I have the right indices. The user provided:
1. sense_key=insight%1:09:02::
2. sense_key=insight%1:12:00::
3. sense_key=insight%1:09:01::
4. sense_key=insight%1:09:00::

So the indices are 1, 2, 3, 4 as listed.

Actually, looking at standard WordNet 3.0 or 3.1:
- insight%1:09:00:: is usually "grasping the inner nature of things intuitively"
- insight%1:09:01:: is usually "the clear (and often sudden) understanding of a complex situation"
- insight%1:09:02:: is usually "clear or deep perception of a situation"
- insight%1:12:00:: is usually "a feeling of understanding"

Given the context about understanding the "basic workings" of cancer through scientific study, this is about deep perception/penetration (sense 1) rather than sudden understanding (sense 3) or intuition (sense 4).

The phrase "fundamental insights" aligns with "deep perception" - getting to the fundamentals.

Also, "penetration" as a synonym fits well with understanding the "inner workings" or "basic workings" of cancer.

Therefore, I choose sense index 1.

But let me reconsider sense 3. Could this be about sudden understanding? The text mentions the discovery "exploded" the field, and the test was the first to predict reliably. But the specific phrase is "fundamental insights about the most basic workings" - this sounds like deep understanding, not necessarily sudden flashes.

In academic/scientific writing, "insights" usually refers to deep understandings or penetrating observations that reveal underlying mechanisms. This aligns with sense 1.

Final decision: sense_index 1.

provider: Chutes


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: basic
Target surface form: basic
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most <t>basic</t> workings of cancer, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=basic%3:00:00:: | definition=pertaining to or constituting a base or basis | examples=a basic fact; the basic ingredients
2. sense_key=basic%5:00:00:standard:01 | definition=reduced to the simplest and most significant form possible without loss of generality | synonyms=canonic, canonical | examples=a basic story line; a canonical syllable pattern
3. sense_key=basic%5:00:02:first:00 | definition=serving as a base or starting point | synonyms=introductory | examples=a basic course in Russian; basic training for raw recruits
4. sense_key=basic%5:00:00:alkaline:00 | definition=of or denoting or of the nature of or containing a base

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "basic" in the given context.

 Let me analyze the context:
 The sentence is: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most <t>basic</t> workings of cancer,"

 The speaker (Samuel Broder) is talking about "basic workings of cancer" - meaning the fundamental, essential, underlying mechanisms or operations of cancer.

 Now let's look at the candidate senses:

 1. sense_key=basic%3:00:00:: | definition=pertaining to or constituting a base or basis | examples=a basic fact; the basic ingredients
    - This seems to fit "basic workings" - the fundamental workings, constituting the basis of how cancer works.

 2. sense_key=basic%5:00:00:standard:01 | definition=reduced to the simplest and most significant form possible without loss of generality | synonyms=canonic, canonical | examples=a basic story line; a canonical syllable pattern
    - This seems more about standardization or canonical forms, not quite fitting "workings of cancer."

 3. sense_key=basic%5:00:02:first:00 | definition=serving as a base or starting point | synonyms=introductory | examples=a basic course in Russian; basic training for raw recruits
    - This is about introductory/elementary level, like beginner courses. "Basic workings" doesn't mean introductory workings here.

 4. sense_key=basic%5:00:00:alkaline:00 | definition=of or denoting or of the nature of or containing a base
    - This is chemical - alkaline. Not relevant here.

 So it's between sense 1 and sense 3.

 Sense 1: "pertaining to or constituting a base or basis" - this aligns with "fundamental" which appears earlier in the sentence ("fundamental insights"). The "basic workings" means the fundamental/underlying mechanisms.

 Sense 3: "serving as a base or starting point" - this is more about being introductory or initial, like "basic training."

 In scientific contexts, "basic research" and "basic workings" refer to fundamental, underlying principles - constituting the basis (sense 1), not introductory level (sense 3).

 The phrase "basic workings of cancer" means the fundamental mechanisms by which cancer operates - the underlying basis.

 Also, later in the text: "but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon."
 "Basic research" in scientific terminology refers to fundamental research (sense 1), not introductory research (sense 3).

 Therefore, sense 1 is the best fit.

 Wait, let me double-check the WordNet senses. In WordNet, "basic" as an adjective:

 - Sense 1: pertaining to or constituting a base or basis ("a basic fact", "the basic ingredients")
 - Sense 2: reduced to the simplest and most significant form possible without loss of generality (canonic, canonical)
 - Sense 3: serving as a base or starting point (introductory) - "a basic course in Russian"
 - Sense 4: of or denoting or of the nature of or containing a base (alkaline)

 In the context: "the most basic workings of cancer" - this means the fundamental operations. "Basic" here modifies "workings" to mean fundamental/underlying.

 And "basic research" later means fundamental research.

 Sense 1 ("pertaining to or constituting a base or basis") captures the meaning of fundamental/underlying/essential.

 Sense 3 is about being at the beginning level (introductory), which doesn't fit.

 So the answer should be sense_index: 1.

 Wait, I need to check the exact format. The user wants:
 {"sense_index": 3}

 But I think it's 1.

 Let me reconsider. Could it be sense 3? "serving as a base or starting point"?
 "Basic workings" - could this mean the starting point workings? No, that doesn't make sense. "Workings" are mechanisms, processes. "Basic workings" means fundamental mechanisms.

 "Basic research" is definitely sense 1 (fundamental research).

 Also, the collocation with "fundamental insights" suggests sense 1, as "fundamental" and "basic" are synonyms here.

 So I'm confident it's sense 1.

provider: Moonshot AI


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: cancer
Target surface form: cancer
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of <t>cancer</t>, "says Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=cancer%1:26:00:: | definition=any malignant growth or tumor caused by abnormal and uncontrolled cell division; it may spread to other parts of the body through the lymphatic system or the blood stream | synonyms=malignant neoplastic disease
2. sense_key=cancer%1:18:00:: | definition=(astrology) a person who is born while the sun is in Cancer | synonyms=Crab
3. sense_key=cancer%1:17:00:: | definition=a small zodiacal constellation in the northern hemisphere; between Leo and Gemini
4. sense_key=cancer%1:15:00:: | definition=the fourth sign of the zodiac; the sun is in this sign from about June 21 to July 22 | synonyms=Cancer the Crab, Crab
5. sense_key=cancer%1:05:00:: | definition=type genus of the family Cancridae | synonyms=genus Cancer

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the target word "cancer" in the given context.

Let me analyze the context:
- The text is about retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene
- It mentions "developing the rare cancer"
- It mentions "predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer"
- It mentions "field of cancer study"
- It mentions "National Cancer Institute"
- It mentions "fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer"
- It's clearly about the disease, not astrology or zodiac signs or crabs (the animal)

Looking at the candidate senses:
1. sense_key=cancer%1:26:00:: - any malignant growth or tumor caused by abnormal and uncontrolled cell division... (the disease)
2. sense_key=cancer%1:18:00:: - astrology person born while sun is in Cancer
3. sense_key=cancer%1:17:00:: - zodiacal constellation
4. sense_key=cancer%1:15:00:: - fourth sign of zodiac
5. sense_key=cancer%1:05:00:: - type genus of family Cancridae (crabs)

The context is clearly about the disease "cancer" - malignant neoplastic disease. The text discusses tumors, genes, the National Cancer Institute, and developing cancer as a medical condition.

Therefore, the correct sense is sense 1 (index 1).

I need to return only a JSON object: {"sense_index": 1}


[System] You are an English linguist performing fine-grained Word Sense Disambiguation. WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense. Do not hedge. Choose the single best indexed sense.

[User]
Target lemma: say
Target surface form: says
Context:
Because of the isolation of the retinoblastoma tumor-suppressor gene, it became possible last January to find out what threat the Quinlan baby faced. A test using new "genetic probes "showed that little Will Quinlan had not inherited a damaged retinoblastoma supressor gene and, therefore, faced no more risk than other children of developing the rare cancer. "It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan. This test was the first to predict reliably whether an individual could expect to develop cancer. Equally important, the initial discovery of the gene that controls retinal cell growth, made by a Boston doctor named Thaddeus Dryja, has opened a field of cancer study, which in recent months has exploded. "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, "<t>says</t> Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute. "All this may not be obvious to the public, which is concerned about advances in treatment, but I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon. "

Candidate senses:
1. sense_key=say%2:32:00:: | definition=express in words | synonyms=state, tell | examples=He said that he wanted to marry her; tell me what is bothering you
2. sense_key=say%2:32:01:: | definition=report or maintain | synonyms=allege, aver | examples=He alleged that he was the victim of a crime; He said it was too late to intervene in the war
3. sense_key=say%2:32:03:: | definition=express a supposition | synonyms=suppose | examples=Let us say that he did not tell the truth; Let's say you had a lot of money--what would you do?
4. sense_key=say%2:42:00:: | definition=have or contain a certain wording or form | synonyms=read | examples=The passage reads as follows; What does the law say?
5. sense_key=say%2:32:04:: | definition=give instructions to or direct somebody to do something with authority | synonyms=order, tell, enjoin | examples=I said to him to go home; She ordered him to do the shopping
6. sense_key=say%2:32:02:: | definition=speak, pronounce, or utter in a certain way | synonyms=pronounce, articulate, enounce, sound out, enunciate | examples=She pronounces French words in a funny way; I cannot say `zip wire'
7. sense_key=say%2:32:07:: | definition=communicate or express nonverbally | examples=What does this painting say?; Did his face say anything about how he felt?
8. sense_key=say%2:32:15:: | definition=utter aloud | examples=She said `Hello' to everyone in the office
9. sense_key=say%2:32:13:: | definition=state as one's opinion or judgement; declare | examples=I say let's forget this whole business
10. sense_key=say%2:32:08:: | definition=recite or repeat a fixed text | examples=Say grace; She said her `Hail Mary'
11. sense_key=say%2:32:09:: | definition=indicate | examples=The clock says noon

Instructions:
1. Choose the single best indexed sense for the target word in context.
2. WordNet glosses are schematic; use the context, synonyms, and examples together.
3. Do not answer with a WordNet sense key.
4. Return only a JSON object exactly like {"sense_index": 3}.

reasoning_content:
 The user wants me to perform Word Sense Disambiguation for the word "says" in the given context. I need to choose the best sense from the 11 candidate senses provided.

 Let me look at the context for the target word "says":

 The sentence is: `"It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer, " <t>says</t> Samuel Broder, director of the National Cancer Institute.`

 So Samuel Broder is the subject of "says", and he is expressing his opinion or making a statement about the research. He's explaining that studying retinoblastoma has led to fundamental insights about cancer.

 Now let's look at the candidate senses:

 1. sense_key=say%2:32:00:: | definition=express in words | synonyms=state, tell | examples=He said that he wanted to marry her; tell me what is bothering you
 2. sense_key=say%2:32:01:: | definition=report or maintain | synonyms=allege, aver | examples=He alleged that he was the victim of a crime; He said it was too late to intervene in the war
 3. sense_key=say%2:32:03:: | definition=express a supposition | synonyms=suppose | examples=Let us say that he did not tell the truth; Let's say you had a lot of money--what would you do?
 4. sense_key=say%2:42:00:: | definition=have or contain a certain wording or form | synonyms=read | examples=The passage reads as follows; What does the law say?
 5. sense_key=say%2:32:04:: | definition=give instructions to or direct somebody to do something with authority | synonyms=order, tell, enjoin | examples=I said to him to go home; She ordered him to do the shopping
 6. sense_key=say%2:32:02:: | definition=speak, pronounce, or utter in a certain way | synonyms=pronounce, articulate, enounce, sound out, enunciate | examples=She pronounces French words in a funny way; I cannot say `zip wire'
 7. sense_key=say%2:32:07:: | definition=communicate or express nonverbally | examples=What does this painting say?; Did his face say anything about how he felt?
 8. sense_key=say%2:32:15:: | definition=utter aloud | examples=She said `Hello' to everyone in the office
 9. sense_key=say%2:32:13:: | definition=state as one's opinion or judgement; declare | examples=I say let's forget this whole business
 10. sense_key=say%2:32:08:: | definition=recite or repeat a fixed text | examples=Say grace; She said her `Hail Mary'
 11. sense_key=say%2:32:09:: | definition=indicate | examples=The clock says noon

 The context shows Samuel Broder making a statement about scientific research - he's expressing his opinion or observation about the significance of the research. He's stating something as a fact or opinion.

 Looking at the candidates:
 - Sense 1 (express in words/state/tell): This is a very general sense. He is expressing something in words.
 - Sense 9 (state as one's opinion or judgement; declare): This seems very fitting because he's stating his opinion/judgment about the research.
 - Sense 2 (report or maintain/allege/aver): This involves reporting or maintaining something to be the case, often with a connotation of claiming without proof (allege), but can also mean asserting. The example "He said it was too late to intervene in the war" is similar.

 Let me look more carefully at the exact usage. Samuel Broder is quoted as saying: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer..."

 This is him expressing his expert opinion or making a statement about the significance of the research.

 Sense 9: "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare" - examples: "I say let's forget this whole business"

 Sense 1: "express in words" - very general

 Sense 2: "report or maintain" - examples include "He said it was too late to intervene in the war"

 Actually, looking at WordNet structure, sense 1 is usually the most general "utter" sense. But the specific context here is someone in authority (director of NCI) making a statement about scientific findings.

 However, looking at the examples for sense 9: "I say let's forget this whole business" - this is suggesting something, stating an opinion about what to do.

 For sense 1: "He said that he wanted to marry her" - this is a straightforward statement of fact or expression.

 But wait, looking at the gloss for sense 1: "express in words" and synonyms "state, tell". The example is reporting what someone said.

 Sense 2: "report or maintain" - this is like alleging or asserting something to be true.

 In the context, Samuel Broder is asserting/declaring that the research has led to fundamental insights. He's making a statement of opinion/judgment about the scientific significance.

 Sense 9 seems quite good: "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare"

 But let me check if there's a pattern in WordNet. Usually, journalists use "says" to introduce quotes. In journalistic contexts, "says" is often used to attribute statements to speakers.

 Looking at the first occurrence in the text: `"It made our New Year, "says Mr. Quinlan.`
 And the second: `"It turns out... " says Samuel Broder`

 These are both direct quotes being attributed to speakers. In WordNet, the most common sense for this usage is usually sense 1 (express in words/state/tell) or sense 9 (state as one's opinion).

 Let me reconsider sense 9's example: "I say let's forget this whole business" - this is an optative or hortative use, suggesting something.

 But Samuel Broder is not suggesting something in the quote provided; he's stating a fact about scientific research ("It turns out that...").

 Sense 2: "report or maintain" - "He said it was too late to intervene in the war" - this fits well with reporting a state of affairs.

 Actually, looking carefully at WordNet 3.1 or similar versions:
 - say%2:32:00:: is usually "express in words" (most general)
 - say%2:32:01:: is "report or maintain" (assert, allege)
 - say%2:32:13:: is "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare"

 The distinction between 1 and 9 might be subtle. Sense 9 specifically mentions "opinion or judgement" and "declare". Broder is declaring something - stating his expert opinion.

 However, looking at the first example with Mr. Quinlan: "It made our New Year," says Mr. Quinlan. This is a straightforward statement of fact (how he felt).

 For journalistic attribution of direct quotes, WordNet usually maps to sense 1 (the first sense) unless there's something specific about it being an opinion (sense 9) or an allegation (sense 2).

 But sense 9 says "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare". The example "I say let's forget this whole business" is somewhat different - it's a proposal.

 Let me look at sense 2 again: "report or maintain". The example "He said it was too late to intervene in the war" is similar to Broder saying "It turns out that...". He's reporting/maintaining that this is the case.

 Actually, looking at the content: Broder is explaining the significance of the research. He's stating his professional opinion.

 But I need to be careful. In many WSD datasets, when journalists use "says" to introduce a quote, it maps to sense 1 (the most general verbal sense).

 However, looking at the options, sense 1 synonyms are "state, tell". Sense 9 is "state as one's opinion or judgement".

 The quote from Broder is clearly his judgement/opinion about the research: "I am convinced this basic research will begin showing results there soon" and "It turns out that...".

 Actually, looking at the full quote: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer," says Samuel Broder.

 This is him stating his opinion/judgement about the scientific implications.

 Also: "All this may not be obvious to the public... but I am convinced..."

 So he's expressing his opinion and judgement.

 Sense 9: "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare" seems very appropriate.

 But let me double-check if sense 1 could be better. Sense 1 is more general: "express in words". While technically correct, sense 9 is more specific and captures that he's declaring his opinion.

 However, looking at standard WordNet sense distinctions, sense 1 is the hypernym for many of these. But when a specific sense like 9 applies, we should choose it.

 Wait, I should look at the examples provided for each sense to see which fits best.

 Sense 1 examples: "He said that he wanted to marry her" - stating a fact/desire
 Sense 9 examples: "I say let's forget this whole business" - suggesting, declaring an opinion

 Broder's statement is an assertion about scientific fact (as he sees it), not a suggestion like "let's forget this". But it is his judgement/opinion.

 Sense 2: "report or maintain" - "He alleged that he was the victim of a crime" (claiming something to be true, often controversially). Broder isn't alleging; he's stating a scientific consensus or his expert view.

 Between sense 1 and sense 9:
 - Sense 1: express in words (general)
 - Sense 9: state as one's opinion or judgement (specific)

 Given that he's the director of NCI and discussing the implications of research, and he uses phrases like "I am convinced", this is clearly him stating his opinion/judgement.

 However, looking at the first instance: "It made our New Year," says Mr. Quinlan. This is also an expression of his sentiment/opinion.

 Actually, looking at WordNet documentation, sense 9 (say%2:32:13::) is often used for expressions like "I say we go" or stating opinions.

 But in the context of journalism, "says" usually maps to sense 1 unless it's specifically about giving instructions (sense 5) or pronouncing (sense 6) etc.

 Let me reconsider the lexical semantics. The word "says" here is functioning as a verb of communication introducing direct speech.

 In WordNet, the first sense (say%2:32:00::) is defined as "express in words" and has examples like "He said that he wanted to marry her". This covers the general case of verbal communication.

 Sense 9 is more specific about stating opinions.

 But looking at the actual WordNet 3.1 entries (which these keys seem to correspond to):
 - say%2:32:00:: express in words; "He said that he wanted to marry her"; "Tell me what is bothering you"
 - say%2:32:01:: report or maintain; "He alleged that he was the victim of a crime"; "The registrar says that I owe the school money"
 - say%2:32:13:: state as one's opinion or judgement; declare; "I say let's forget this whole business"

 The example for sense 2 includes "The registrar says that I owe the school money" which is similar to journalistic attribution.

 But for expert commentary like Broder's, stating his opinion on scientific matters, sense 9 seems appropriate.

 However, I should check if sense 13 is actually sense 9 in the list. The user lists them as:
 9. sense_key=say%2:32:13::
 10. sense_key=say%2:32:08::
 11. sense_key=say%2:32:09::

 So index 9 in the list corresponds to sense_key say%2:32:13::.

 Index 1 corresponds to say%2:32:00::
 Index 2 corresponds to say%2:32:01::

 Now, looking at the content again: Samuel Broder is making an authoritative statement about cancer research. He's not just "expressing in words" in a general sense, but specifically stating his expert opinion/judgement.

 However, the most common sense for "says" introducing a quote in English is sense 1. But the task asks for fine-grained disambiguation.

 Let me look at the distinction between "state" (sense 1) and "state as one's opinion" (sense 9). Sense 9 captures the subjective nature of the statement.

 But actually, looking at the example for sense 9: "I say let's forget this whole business" - this is hortative/commendatory. It's proposing a course of action.

 Broder's statement is assertive, declaring a fact about the research ("It turns out that...").

 So sense 2 "report or maintain" might be better? "He said it was too late to intervene in the war" - asserting that a state of affairs exists.

 Or sense 1, the general sense.

 Actually, looking at WordNet's hierarchy, sense 9 is a hyponym of sense 1, specializing in stating opinions.

 Given the context shows Broder giving his professional assessment, sense 9 is probably the intended sense.

 But I want to be careful. Let me see if there's any other clue.

 The sentence structure: `"It turns out... ," says Samuel Broder...`

 In journalistic writing, this is the standard attribution formula. In most lexical resources, this maps to the general communication sense.

 However, looking at the synonyms for sense 1: "state, tell". For sense 9, the gloss explicitly mentions "declare".

 Broder is declaring the importance of the research.

 But let's look at sense 2 again: "report or maintain". The example "The registrar says that I owe the school money" is very similar to "Samuel Broder says that studying... made possible insights..."

 Actually, looking at the exact quote: "It turns out that studying a tragic but uncommon tumor made possible some fundamental insights about the most basic workings of cancer,"

 This is indirect speech within the direct quote, but the "says" introduces the whole statement.

 I think sense 1 (express in words) or sense 9 (state as opinion) are the main candidates.

 Given that the user asks for "fine-grained" disambiguation and sense 9 specifically captures "state as one's opinion or judgement", and Broder is clearly giving his expert opinion, I should choose sense 9.

 Wait, I need to check if sense 13 (which is index 9) is indeed "state as one's opinion". The user lists:
 9. sense_key=say%2:32:13:: | definition=state as one's opinion or judgement; declare

 Yes.

 But I should verify the WordNet sense keys to make sure I understand the numbering correctly. The index in the JSON should be the position in the list (1-indexed).

 So if I choose sense_key say%2:32:13::, the index is 9.

 However, I'm concerned that sense 9 might be too specific. Let me reconsider.

 The example for sense 9 is: "I say let's forget this whole business"
 This is suggestive: "I say we do X"

 Broder's quote is: "It turns out that..." and "I am convinced..."

 This is not "I say let's do X", but rather stating observations and convictions.

 Sense 2: "report or maintain" - examples: "He alleged..." "He said it was too late..."
 This involves asserting something to be the case.

 Sense 1: general expression.

 Actually, looking at WordNet's actual database, sense 2 (say%2:32:01::) is defined as "report or maintain; `He alleged that he was the victim of a crime'; `He said it was too late to intervene in the war'; `The registrar says that I owe the school money'"

 This "reporting" sense fits well with journalistic attribution where someone is quoted as saying something.

 But sense 1 is also used.

 In fine-grained WSD, we should choose the most specific applicable sense.

 Between sense 2 (report/maintain) and sense 9 (state opinion):
 - Sense 2 emphasizes reporting a state of affairs or maintaining a claim.
 - Sense 9 emphasizes stating an opinion or judgement.

 Broder is doing both, but the content is his professional opinion/judgement about the significance of research.

 However, looking at the first "says" in the text: "It made our New Year," says Mr. Quinlan.
 This is Mr. Quinlan stating his feelings/opinion about the news. This would also fit sense 9.

 But wait, the target is the second "says" (the one marked with <t> tags).

 Actually, looking at the context provided, the <t> tags surround the second "says" only.

 So we need to disambiguate: `"It turns out... ," <t>says</t> Samuel Broder...`

 Given that Broder is the director of the National Cancer Institute and is discussing scientific research, and he says "I am convinced...", his statement is clearly an expression of his opinion and judgement.

 Therefore, sense 9 (index 9) seems the most appropriate.

 But I need to make sure about the format. The user wants: {"sense_index": 9}

 Wait, I should double-check if sense 1 might actually be the correct answer for a different reason. Sometimes in WSD, the most frequent sense is chosen when senses are hard to distinguish, but the instructions say to use context, examples, and synonyms to choose the best indexed sense, and not to hedge.

 Let me look at the synonyms again:
 - Sense 1: state, tell
 - Sense 9: (no synonyms listed, just examples)

 Actually, looking at the list:
 9. sense_key=say%2:32:13:: | definition=state as one's opinion or judgement; declare | examples=I say let's forget this whole business

 The example "I say let's forget this whole business" is somewhat idiomatic. It means "I propose/declare that we should forget..."

 Broder's statement is a declaration of his view.

 Another thought: In many WSD test sets, "say" in journalistic contexts maps to sense 1.

 But let's look at sense 2 again: "report or maintain". This is for when you say something is the case (allege, aver).

 Broder is averring that the research has led to insights.

 Actually, looking carefully at the WordNet glosses provided in the prompt, sense 2 has synonyms "allege, aver". These have a connotation of claiming without proof or asserting strongly.

 Sense 9 doesn't have synonyms listed, but the definition mentions "declare".

 Given the context of scientific reporting, "declare" or "state" (sense 1) fit.

 I think sense 1 is the safest choice if I'm unsure, but sense 9 is more precise for opinion statements.

 Let me reconsider the example for sense 9. "I say let's forget this whole business" uses "say" to introduce a proposal. Broder is not proposing something; he's explaining a scientific development.

 So sense 9 might not fit well.

 Sense 2: "report or maintain" - he's reporting on the state of research.

 Sense 1: "express in words" - he's expressing his thoughts.

 Actually, looking at the WordNet hierarchy, sense 2 is a specific kind of saying where you report or maintain something to be true.

 Given the quote content: "It turns out that..." - he's reporting a finding.

 So sense 2 could work.

 But the general sense 1 is also very applicable.

 Let me check if there's a pattern. The first "says" (Mr. Quinlan) is expressing emotion. The second (Broder) is expressing scientific opinion.

 Both are general "express in words".

 However, looking at the specific wording of sense 2: "report or maintain". The example "He said it was too late to intervene in the war" is very similar to "He said it turns out that studying... made possible..."

 Both are statements about how things are (or turned out to be).

 But sense 1 covers this too.

 In fine-grained WSD, if a more specific sense applies, we should use it. But if the specific sense is too specific (like sense 9 being for hortative "I say we go"), then we should use the general sense.

 Let me look at the definition of sense 9 again: "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare"

 Broder is declaring his opinion.

 But the example suggests a specific construction.

 Perhaps I should look at the index numbers. The user lists 11 senses.

 Sense 1: say%2:32:00::
 Sense 2: say%2:32:01::
 Sense 3: say%2:32:03::
 Sense 4: say%2:42:00::
 Sense 5: say%2:32:04::
 Sense 6: say%2:32:02::
 Sense 7: say%2:32:07::
 Sense 8: say%2:32:15::
 Sense 9: say%2:32:13::
 Sense 10: say%2:32:08::
 Sense 11: say%2:32:09::

 Wait, the lexicographic file numbers (the %2:32:XX part) don't match the index order. For example, sense 9 has %2:32:13:: which is lexicographically after sense 10's %2:32:08::?

 Actually, WordNet sense keys use the lexicographer file name and then a lex_id. The format is word%pos:lex_file_num:lex_id:. The lex_id determines the order, but the numbering in the prompt (1-11) is arbitrary listing.

 So I should just go by the index numbers provided (1-11).

 Now, between 1, 2, and 9:

 Context analysis:
 - Subject: Samuel Broder (expert)
 - Content: Scientific opinion about research implications
 - Structure: Direct quote attribution

 Sense 1 (express in words): Very general. Fits.
 Sense 2 (report or maintain): Fits for stating facts.
 Sense 9 (state as one's opinion or judgement): Fits for stating opinions.

 Given that he says "I am convinced..." later, and he's assessing the research ("fundamental insights"), this is his judgement.

 But the example for sense 9 ("I say let's forget...") is different from declarative statements of fact/opinion like "It turns out that..."

 Actually, "It turns out that..." is an observation, not necessarily an opinion.

 I think sense 1 is the most standard choice for journalistic "says" introducing quotes.

 However, the presence of sense 9 suggests that "say" can specifically mean "state one's opinion".

 Let me check if there's any other clue. The word "says" is used twice in the text. The first time by Mr. Quinlan, the second by Broder. The first is expressing relief/happiness. The second is expressing scientific assessment.

 Both are statements of the speakers' views.

 But sense 9's example is very specific to the "I say (that) we should..." construction.

 I think I should go with sense 1. It's the most general and covers verbal communication of ideas.

 But wait, looking at the instruction: "WordNet glosses are schematic. Use the sentence context, the examples, and the synonyms to choose the best indexed sense."

 The gloss for 1 is "express in words".
 The gloss for 9 is "state as one's opinion or judgement; declare".

 If Broder is declaring his opinion, sense 9 is better.

 But is he declaring his opinion or reporting a finding? The text says "It turns out...", which suggests he's stating a fact about what has been discovered, albeit one that requires expert interpretation.

 Given the ambiguity, and the fact that sense 1 is the primary sense for communication verbs, and sense 9 might be restricted to specific constructions (like the example shows), I will choose sense 1.

 Actually, no. Looking at the WordNet entry for say, sense 9 (word sense 13 in the database) is indeed for stating opinions, typically in constructions like "I say (that)...", often with an element of authority or declaration.

 Given that Broder is an authority figure (director of NCI) making an authoritative statement, and the content is his judgement ("I am convinced..."), sense 9 is appropriate.

 However, I'm going to reconsider sense 2. "Report or maintain" with synonyms "allege, aver". Alleging is often used for claims that may not be proven, or in legal contexts. Averring is asserting strongly. Broder is averring.

 But "allege" has a negative or tentative connotation (claim without proof), while Broder is stating expert consensus or observation.

 So sense 2 is less likely.

 Between 1 and 9:
 I'll go with 1 as the most general, safe choice, but I think 9 is defensible.

 Actually, looking at similar WSD tasks, when a speaker attributes their own opinion in a quote, and the sense list includes a specific "opinion" sense, it's often the right choice.

 But let's look at the first "says" again. "It made our New Year," says Mr. Quinlan. This is stating his feeling/opinion. If both map to the same sense, and sense 9 is for opinions, then both would map to sense 9.

 However, in WordNet, sense 9 might be lexically restricted.

 Let me check the lex_id 13 vs 00. In WordNet, lower lex_ids are usually more frequent. Sense 1 (lex_id 00) is the most frequent.

 In the absence of clear evidence that the specific sense 9 applies (especially given its specific example), and given that sense 1 is the standard sense for "utter words", I will choose sense 1.

 Final check: The target is "says" (3rd person singular present). The context is standard journalistic attribution. The definition "express in words" fits perfectly. The synonyms "state, tell" fit. The example "He said that he wanted to marry her" is structurally identical (subject + say + that-clause/content).

 Sense 9's example "I say let's forget this whole business" is different (suggesting, proposing).

 Therefore, sense 1 is the better choice.

 Index: 1

 Wait, I want to make absolutely sure. Is there any reason to choose sense 9 over sense 1?

 Sense 1: "express in words"
 Sense 9: "state as one's opinion or judgement"

 If Broder is stating his opinion, sense 9 is more precise. But "express in words" also covers stating opinions.

 However, the example for sense 1 shows "He said that he wanted to marry her" - this is expressing a desire (which is an opinion/feeling).

 So sense 1 covers opinions too.

 Given that sense 9 has a very specific example that doesn't match the declarative statement here, and sense 1 is the general sense for this construction, I choose sense 1.

 Actually, one last check: Is it possible that sense 2 is correct? "Report or maintain"?
 Example: "He said it was too late to intervene in the war"
 This is structurally: He said [clause stating a fact/judgement about time].

 Broder's quote: He says [clause stating a fact/judgement about research].

 This matches sense 2 very well.

 Sense 1 example: "He said that he wanted to marry her" - this is reporting a desire.

 The difference between sense 1 and sense 2 in WordNet is that sense 2 specifically involves asserting or maintaining something to be the case (allege, aver), whereas sense 1 is just verbal expression.

 Broder is asserting that studying the tumor made possible insights. He's maintaining a position about the scientific facts.

 This is closer to sense 2 than sense 1.

 But sense 1 is broader and includes sense 2-like usages.

 Given the fine-grained nature, and that sense 2 exists specifically for "report or maintain", but has synonyms with potentially negative connotations (allege), while Broder's statement is positive expert opinion...

 I'm overthinking this. The standard sense for "says" in "X says [quote]" is sense 1.

 I'll go with sense 1.

 Index: 1

provider: DigitalOcean